I've played Terra Mystica 7-8 times and played Gaia Project for the first time this week. That said, if you like more non interactive games that have oodles of mechanics to explore, go for GP. GP is good at 2, 3, and 4p and offers a 1p option which I've tried (not for me but lots of others love it). Many people (myself included) have serious warping issues with the first printing of this game (YMMV). Also note that double shovel is at 5 and not at 6, meaning that it remains contested even with multiple players investing into terraforming. I’ve played it. Rules ; Subscriptions ; Bookmarks ; Search ; Account ; Moderators; Recommend . 90% Upvoted. A játékot az Év Játékának jelölték 2017-ben (BGG), illetve ebben az évben több, összesen 2 másik jelölést is kapott. The companies’ partnership started in 2018 with Fuji and Magnastorm.But now, Terra Mystica and Gaia Project—ranked 14th and 9th overall on BoardGameGeek—will be releasing, along with their expansions, in English due to the collaboration between Capstone and Feuerland. TM hat ja reichlich Lorbeeren geerntet und GP sollte die konsequente Weiterentwicklung sein. … Gaia project is good at all player counts. In diesem Video beschreibe ich euch alle Unterschiede der beiden Spiele Gaia Project und Terra Mystica. It will almost definitely be replacing Terra Mystica on our shelf. Lautsprecher. Otherwise as far as the games go I prefer GP but with the amount of content for TM you cant really go wrong there either. Projet Gaia : Terra Mystica dans l'espace ? GP is a bit longer, but that's really because there are more options available to pore through. It is a nice variant if you have played Terra Mystica to death, but if I had to choose between them, Terra edges out Gaia. ... Un Œil sur PROJET GAIA – Dans l’Univers de Terra Mystica. It is still best at 3+, but it is really good at 2. level 2 Will check it out! The round to round puzzle and end game scoring is more dynamic in GP. CTGZM7240 Terra Mystica. I now own Gaia and under no circumstance would I ever choose the other one over it, TM is much tighter, which makes positioning important. report. In both cases, you had the power you needed, you just needed to burn more in the first example to get there. Oh oui, terriblement C’est Terra Mystica, revu et revampé ( attention, paragraphe lourd, dense et chargé ) Un matos amélioré, des fig plutôt que des pièces en bois (mais le bois, c’est quand même tellement plus chaud et organique), un plateau modulaire qui modifie chaque config de parties, pas fixe comme Terra Mystica, des illustrations plus techno, un thème SF plus vendeur. Spielend für Toleranz. Get Terra Mystica. Wie der Titel schon verrät, ist das Spiel der Nachfolger von Terra Mystica, dem international sehr erfolgreichen, vielfach ausgezeichneten Spiel aus dem Jahr 2015.. True to the foundations that made Terra Mystica a massive success, this box invites one to four players to forge their own galactic empires. They don't seem to have any connection between their name, their art, and their abilities. TM's main issue for me was that it was only really good at 3 or 4 players (2 lacks competition while 5p is too crowded). In Gaia you generally start with way less power tokens so early power burns are not as obvious and there are many ways to gain new power so it will ebb and flow throughout the game. Sickerflopp-Liebhaber. Mai 2017; 93; Verzeiht mir den emotionalen Ausbruch... aber das Cover ist brutal häßlich! J'ai toujours bien aimé mais je n'ai pas le public pour (mais j'ai quand même passé le cap de l'achat pour Gaia Project). Autoren: Helge Ostertag & Jens Drögemüller Spieler: 1-4 Alter: ab 14 Dauer: 60-150min UVP: 69,90 Euro . In Gaia there are two extra tracks, but they are no longer majority scoring! Quand nous nous sommes intéressés à Projet Gaia, l'argument : "Terra Mystica en mieux" ne pouvait qu'enfoncer le clou d'avantage : il nous fallait ce jeu. Gaia Project is the better game without really putting any additional weight or complexity on top. For that reason alone it is worth exploring GP, even if you love TM. However, I still think they can coexist as the general feel of the games is a bit different even though Gaia definitely is a successor to TM. Granted, I'm sure it's very hard to do this with aliens compared to fantasy races. What Terra Mystica does better: Terra Mystica is tight.
Press J to jump to the feed. Diese werden im Laufe des Spiels in verschiedene Arten aufgewertet. As if Terra Mystica weren’t a fantastic achievement in board gaming in its own right, Gaia Project is a souped up version IN SPACE. Paru en 2013, ... Projet Gaia. Des déplacements entre terrains plus importants, qui … Instead you get lump sum points for being high on them and they each give ongoing or one time bonuses as you go up. First, it allows for better gameplay at lower player counts (and adds a great Solo mode!). As others have said the research track is vastly superior to the cult tracks in TM. Your Tags: Add tags. Creates extra layer of depth to power management, since you don't burn this power, but it is tied for the round and next income phase. April 2016; 2; Interessant auf jeden Fall - Da müsste nur für mich ein 1 bis 4 Spieler. Races are even more different, but they are less "leaning" towards a certain playstyle. I prefer Gaia and see it as a refinement on the previous game in a few ways. Less VP and more customization options for the races, which change game-to-game since they are a part of a set up. Einmal editiert, zuletzt von Puma (22. True to the foundations that made Terra Mystica a massive success, this box invites one to four players to forge their own galactic empires. Playing Clans just makes me want to play Terra Mystica more, and Clans ultimately feels very milquetoast and vanilla by comparison. - Project Gaia: Terra Mystica in Space - Brettspiel-Forum - Bilder von der Spiel 2015 | The Board Game Journal - Essenský Spiel 2015 - den 3. Clans of Caledonia was actually not on my radar at all until some of the recommendations here. Posted by. save. Almost all of them think GP is better than TM (and all agree that it is at least as good). I was a longtime TM fan, and honestly doubted that a new game would replace it, but now I'd say Gaia Project is definitely my favorite. This makes everything much different game to game. Let's say you need 5 power right now, so you burn to get enough. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Einmal editiert, zuletzt von SpaceTrucker (28. I thought it was fantastic and am super excited to try it again. Personally id say Gaia project is the better game overall, mostly because its better at all player counts but that I prefer Terra mystica because I find the game a bit cleaner in its design. The variable set up if the tech tiles is also a great idea, which makes players rethink what tracks they wish to focus on from game to game. Gaia Project is a new game in the line of Terra Mystica. The only reason I would go with TM is if theme is huge for you and you like fantasy much much more than science fiction. Clans totally ripped off the far superior Terra Mystica, and it’s interesting to me how everyone is cool with it. Jeder Spieler übernimmt eines von 14 Völkern und besiedelt die Planeten einer Galaxie, indem verschiedene Gebäude darauf errichtet werden. I always liked TM, but the “spend your power till you have 6-7 fast” group think bugged me. Q.I.C. I will admit that I think I prefer TMs classic wooden pieces vs the plastic in Gaia but all together I don’t see myself playing TM again when Gaia is ever an alternate option. I really don't see a reason to own both and would just dive into GP. Feuerland Spiele Gaia Project 13 Strategiespiel für 1 bis 4 Spieler; Sprache: Deutsch; Spieldauer 60-150 Minuten; 2. Terra Mystica is not vastly inferiour, it's just not quite as elegant in its design. Ou moins, tout dépend de ses goûts et sensibilité et si l’on préfère les sirènes aux aliens. It is pretty much Terra Mystica (in space!) The cult tracks are rather boring in TM, but GP fixes this. No, the core principals are more or less the same, which is great. The biggest change is that they’ve incorporated the “cult track” more into the game and the rewards for working up the tech trees of it are more thematic and better. At this point I think GP edges out TM for me. It is so much more bloated than TM in mechanics it's not even close. My highest scored game (214) was Hadsch Hallas (Some BGG users think of it as the weakest race for some reason) with Nav0. Capstone will begin printing new editions of all titles and expansions within the next few weeks. Gaia all the way. Terra Mystica is not vastly inferiour, it's just not quite as elegant in its design. Feuerland Spiele Terra Mystica: Big Box 21: 92,65€ 2: Feuerland FEU63564 Terra Mystica: Die Händler: 37,28€ 3: Z-Man Games ZMG71240 - Terra Mystica Brettspiel: 64,96€ 4: Feuerland Spiele Gaia Project 13: 65,78€ 5: Feuerland Spiele EIN Fest für Odin 08: 57,00€ 6 In that regard, TM feels a bit more restrictive (which can be be good or bad, depending on one's subjective opinion). Here races are more customizable, courtesy of a more flexible tech track and variability of tech tile/track pairings. I'm not talking about the plastic pieces, I'm ok with those. Join our community! Terra Mystica: Gaia Project | Board Game | BoardGameGeek. The only reason for me to recommend Terra Mystica would be the theme. It's a different story if you're mainly going to play with 2 players. Terra Mystica. These moments happen far more often in TM than they do in GP and for that reason I enjoy TM more. What Gaia Project does better: The technology track is far and away the biggest improvement of GP. Games might look very similar on the surface, but they are actually quite different. People are eager to jump to conclusions about it being a "re-theme" for a full price and it simply isn't. That seems to be how most people got exposed to GP. terra mystica vs gaia project; Oct 09. Pas une grande expérience (3 parties de Terra Mystica à l'époque de sa sortie et 2 de Gaia Project ce week-end). J'adore Terra Mystica, je trouve que c'est un excellant jeu et nous (mon groupe de joueurs et moi) y avons beaucoup joué. Join our community! However, being able to add power back into your bowls means that burning power is even more powerful (if you’ll pardon the pun) than before. Great solo mode. Solid at every player count. Set your sights on distant stars and strive to colonize the galaxy in Gaia Project, the follow-up to the smash hit Terra Mystica! In unserer Redaktion wird großes Augenmerk auf eine genaue Festlegung des Testverfahrens gelegt sowie der Artikel in der Endphase durch eine abschließenden Testnote bepunktet. It makes it harder to gauge the best plays when it comes to using power. Gaia Project unfortunately improves everything about TM besides the art and components. 22. I am trying to decide which one I want to Exactly correct. Terra Mystica is one of my all-time favorite games, but after 6 plays of Gaia Project, I think GP is even better. [Mod] aus  Gaia Project [yze] Ich lese hier schon länger mit und hadere mit mir, ob sich der Kauf wirklich lohnt. Gaia Project. We bieden bord-, kaart- en dobbelspellen aan en dit voor zowel kinderen, families, koppels, beginnende boardgamers als echte geeks. Online. But I've only played one game. Terra Mystica: Mini Expansion 1. Which do you prefer? More interesting Tech Tiles (blessings). 3. Tight. Is it a completely different game? The mechanics are just plain better. 15 potential combinations, which will force you to adapt in order to win. Come discuss games like Codenames, Arkham Horror, Terra Mystica, and all your other favorite games! Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. Terra Mystica Gaia Project erscheint 2017 Verfasst von Daniel Krause am 16. No partial terraforming means that if you don't go into this tech, two planet types are completely out of reach for you. Reaktionen 2.173 Beiträge 1.288 Karteneintrag ja. 5 5. April 2017) brettundpad. Different opinion here: The minor differences make Gaia Project slightly more fiddly without adding anything substancial. I REALLY like the variable setup of the game. This is not the case in TM, where you are neighbors to leech power but you are also fighting for territory in basically every round. Set your sights on distant stars and strive to colonize the galaxy in Gaia Project, the follow-up to the smash hit Terra Mystica! It is a nice variant if you have played Terra Mystica to death, but if I had to choose between them, Terra edges out Gaia. As in the original Terra Mystica, fourteen different factions live on seven different kinds of planets, and each faction is bound to their own home planets, so to develop and grow, they must terraform neighboring planets into their home environments in competition with the other groups. Pas une grande expérience (3 parties de Terra Mystica à l'époque de sa sortie et 2 de Gaia Project ce week-end). A lot of people are not into space and sci-fi stuff and I personally think that the art style doesn't match that theme too well in GP while it goes perfectly with the fantasy approach of TM. Commun (même si bien sûr adapté à chaque version) : Also: don't trust anyone telling you Navigation is a must-have track. The only reason for me to recommend Terra Mystica would be the theme. Change it to your color, red, and plop a building down. Would you say one or the other is better, or is it minor enough that theme is the main deciding factor to getting either? As much as I love TM, GP is just too much better of a game. Re:Terra Mystica: Gaia Project « Respuesta #25 en: 29 de Octubre de 2017, 19:41:20 » A saber, yo me he leído las reglas en inglés (bajadas de la web de Z-Man), y los componentes que se ven en las fotos que ya se han subido de Essen de la versión alemana, no veo que se diferencien en nada de los gráficos que salen en las instrucciones de la versión en inglés. It makes choosing tracks far more interesting because the track will help dictate your overall strategy. I’m all about TM because of this reason right here. The playmats look almost identical, and it seems to me that the only thing that was changed is the theme from Fantasy to Space. But it’s a solid game. Feuerland Spiele Terra Mystica: Big Box 21: 92,65€ 2: Feuerland FEU63564 Terra Mystica: Die Händler: 37,28€ 3: Z-Man Games ZMG71240 - Terra Mystica Brettspiel: 64,96€ 4: Feuerland Spiele Gaia Project 13: 65,78€ 5: Feuerland Spiele EIN Fest für Odin 08: 57,00€ 6
Terra Mystica is a group favourite, so everyone wants to try it. At the moment I think that Gaia is better than TM. Press J to jump to the feed. Das ermöglicht den Zugriff auf mehr Ressourcen und Aktionen. Two titans face off in a terra/gaiaforming contest of champions! Wer Terra Mystica nicht kennt: Gaia Project ist ein komplexes Aufbauspiel mit vielen Möglichkeiten, Punkte zu generieren, viele gut ineinander verzahnte Mechaniken, Interaktion auf moderatem aber spürbarem Niveau und unzählige Völker, die sich komplett unterschiedlich spielen. Gaia project scales between 2-4 players much better. But it plays very differently, adding a layer of logistics, increased importance of resource management, higher variety of potential goals etc. “spend your power till you have 6-7 fast” group think bugged me. New Thread ; Printer Friendly ; Subscribe ; Bookmark ; Thread Rolls. Second, game component quality is worse in GP. I would argue that nothing about Gaia Project is "smoother" than Terra Mystica. Even if they're playing same races in several games. $79.99 SRP. Faster to set up. I own Gaia Project, Terra Mystica and Clans of Caledonia. The board games are expected to be available during the holiday season in 2020. Allows for calmer planning, since you can be almost 100% certain a particular space will remain uncontested. Overall I didn’t think the changes significant enough to buy it (I already own and love TM) and I prefer TM for personal, thematic reasons. Edit: also, the solo mode is really well done. its actually better to have more power most of the time but its hard because 7c and the priest actions are so good. There are parts where I think the additional complexity is better and worth it (research tracks vs cult tracks, changes to the power bowls), and parts where I think it is worse (Gaia planets). Gaia Project. Gaia Project. New "joker" planet type, which ease out the kinks in building progression. They both have their merits, but I would really look at player count. It's mathematically a really neat mechanic. This is coming from someone who ranks GP and TM as his all-time #1 and #2. We hechten belang aan een vriendelijke service en persoonlijk advies, Aangezien boardgamen onze passie is, schuiven we graag met jullie aan tafel om een spel uit te leggen of te spelen. Just one counterpoint. Come discuss games like Codenames, Arkham Horror, Terra Mystica, and all your other favorite games! Both games were designed by the same people. Power is more flexible and has more uses. J'ai toujours bien aimé mais je n'ai pas le public pour (mais j'ai quand même passé le cap de l'achat pour Gaia Project). Especially the spatial element feels different in Gaia, as the map has a lot more empty space and the neighbour-rules and city/federation-rules are a bit more lenient. You can always calculate your "usable power" as tokens in bowl 3 + (tokens in bowl 2)/2. action: a major improvement over TM's Priests. Malgré un nombre de parties important le jeu sort toujours et nous y prenons toujours du plaisir à y jouer mais (car il y a un mais) il y a des choses qui nous paraissent trop systématique pour entrevoir la victoire et c'est cet aspect la que j'aimerais voir disparaitre. Wir rezensieren den heiß ersehnten, lang erwarteten und mit viel Vorschußlorbeeren bedachten Nachfolger von Terra Mystica. Gaia Project» Forums » General Subject: Gaia Project vs Terra Mystica. Sucks to suck, dude, welcome to TM. Terra Mystica 2. But, you can never go back, and are thus risking maxing out, having too few tokens to do an action you need later, or being unable to burn right now for fear of running out of tokens later. Variable boards, end game scoring, tech tile position, and other things create way more variety and interesting gameplay. 2 Posts. I also like the theme better as well. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. Popular Tags: What does "reimplements" mean? 9 9. comments. The only reason for me to recommend Terra Mystica would be the theme. Par conséquent, pour se … New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. J'ai toujours bien aimé mais je n'ai pas le public pour (mais j'ai quand même passé le cap de l'achat pour Gaia Project). Gaia is a lot better than TM and that is coming from someone who rated TM at 10, with only one other game in the same bracket (Through the Ages). I would say GP is like feast for Odin and TM is like agricola. My only criticism of GP is the aliens. [Projet Gaia] Errata non officiel des règles VF [Aide au choix de jeu] Gaia Project vs Barrage vs Root vs Food Chain Magnate hide. I would argue that nothing about Gaia Project is "smoother" than Terra Mystica. I personally like TM and don't have an interest in GP. In GP, you are offered an extra space in your "neighborhood", which helps give you a space of breathing room even against the most aggressive of players. Feuerland Spiele Terra Mystica: Big Box 21: 92,65€ 2: Feuerland FEU63564 Terra Mystica: Die Händler: 37,28€ 3: Z-Man Games ZMG71240 - Terra Mystica Brettspiel: 64,96€ 4: Feuerland Spiele Gaia Project 13: 65,78€ 5: Feuerland Spiele EIN Fest für Odin 08: 57,00€ 6 Gaia Project is better in every category in my opinion. The modular map is better suited for that. I've played a lot of both. Among my friends who have played GP with me, several are veteran TM players. Februar 2017. PROJET GAIA est un vrai jeu "Expert", prenant l'asymétrie d'expériences comme point de départ à un jeu associant gestion, développement et majorité. Gaia Project is the better game without really putting any additional weight or complexity on top. cubes which serve multiple purposes, such as extending your range, colonizing a Gaia planet or getting a special Q.I.C. I have not played either, but the main reason I am more interested in Gaia Project is that it is supposedly much better with two players than Terra Mystica. I can't think of a single thing terra does better. Gaia Project is the better game without really putting any additional weight or complexity on top. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Burning simply takes two from bowl 2 and converts them to one in bowl 3 - no power gained, you've simply moved things around. Higher race variability. Projet Gaia est un jeu Space Opera dans l’univers du désormais plus que célèbre Terra Mystica. I feel like I should like GP more, but the tightness of the leeching and blocking of TM feels so, so good, even if the balance isn't as good, the strategy isn't as deep, and the cults feel tacked on...Getting blocked hurts, leeching feels awesome. but I still liked it. It adds an entirely new game within the game. Two "goal" tiles in game randomized from a pool of 6. Interesting advanced tech tiles which can be as influential (or even more influential) than the end game bonus "goal tiles". Some new stuff is definitely better(tech track), but a lot of it is just new for the sake of having a bunch of new puzzle pieces onto a game that already has a bunch of them. burning power doesnt make getting power faster. Terra mystica plays best at 4, and doesn't handle lower player counts as well. Spelhuis is een nieuwe Limburgse bordspellenspeciaalzaak. Gaia Project – Ein Terra Mystica Spiel von Helge Ostertag und Jens Drögemöller, erschienen im Feuerland-Verlag, ist ein Spiel für 1 – 4 Personen ab 14 Jahren. I also like the fact that you can add power to your bowls from the supply. 3. It's a different story if you're mainly going to play with 2 players. Terra Mystica is not vastly inferiour, it's just not quite as elegant in its design. Does it mean GP is an improved version and more complete game, based on Terra Mystica? It's a really cool map-building aspect for a Euro, and GP just doesn't feel so focused. Une discussion est en cours dans Hier j'ai joué à... sur les jeux aux règles complexes. Upgrade your structures, gain resources, and progress in six different … Or be really good at what you are doing. It's subtle but makes for some important decisions during the game! A Terra Mystica: Gaia Project egy nagyon összetett társasjáték, 1 - 4 játékos részére, az átlagos játékidő hosszú, akár 1 - 2.5 óra is lehet. GP just gets rid of some of the very few rough spots I found with TM. Harry2017. There are parts where I think the additional complexity is better and worth it (research tracks vs cult tracks, changes to the power bowls), and parts where I think it is worse (Gaia planets). Terra Mystica: Gaia Project. 5 Jahre nach dem weltweiten Erfolg von Terra Mystica kommt nun mit Gaia Project der Nachfolger heraus. 3 hours ago. 4 8 15 16 23 42. As in the original Terra Mystica, fourteen different factions live on seven different kinds of planets, and each faction is bound to their own home planets, so to develop and grow, they must terraform neighboring planets into their home environments in competition with the other groups. It's just random and themeless, which is way different from TM which has factions all with abilities that make sense for what they are. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I felt far less easily trapped in Gaia since you can burn a specific resource to fly farther, and all of space essentiallY acts like the river in TM. Oh, you also cut off his network which would connect across this river space? Gaia is great at any count where TM shines at 4. The #1 reddit source for news, information, and discussion about modern board games and board game culture. For those who played both - would it be best to get Terra Mystica first and go for Gaia Project later (as sort of an “expansion”)?